Perhaps a revolution is not what we need

Malcolm Gladwell joins a rising chorus of skeptics in his latest piece for the New Yorker, Small change: Why the revolution will not be tweeted. Responding to what he calls an “outsized enthusiasm” for social media technologies as activist tools, he argues that the weak ties enabled by services like Twitter cannot inspire the kind of commitment and bravery required of “high-risk activism” like the civil rights movement.

It’s a compelling argument and, to his credit, Gladwell works hard to name the sources of this “enthusiasm”. Among his slacktivist hall of shame: oversold “Twitter Revolutions” in Moldova and Iran, massive awareness campaigns on Facebook, and the Legend of the Stolen Cellphone (as told by Clay Shirky).

Despite careful attention to some very real weaknesses of network activism, Gladwell’s argument suffers from a lack of detail in two important areas: technology and history.

What is “Twitter”?

Three different Twitter clients

Twitter is the representative social media technology throughout most of Gladwell’s article. But as an admitted non-user, Gladwell overlooks features and user scenarios that would add a critical complexity to his argument. Like email or the telephone, Twitter is a non-prescriptive communication platform. Each user experiences “Twitter” differently depending on the time of day and frequency she checks her feed, the other people she follows, and the interface(s) she uses to access the network. Because of this flexibility, norms emerge, mutate, collide, and fade away among Twitter users with a fluidity that may not be easily apprehendable to a non-user like Gladwell.

Twitter may feel like a new phenomenon but listen closely and you will find echoes of older technological paradigms at its borders. A Twitter feed is expressed using the same protocols that syndicate blog content and its famous 140-character limit ensures compatibility with a text messaging standard from 1985. These design decisions afford Twitter data a powerful mobility. You can subscribe to a Twitter feed with an blog reader and send a tweet from any old mobile phone. Technically speaking, there is little “new” about it.

Although Andrew Sullivan and others initially reported that the 2009 protests in Iran were coordinated by Twitter, it turns out that most of the Twitter activity was taking place in Europe and the U.S.. This narrative meets the needs of Gladwell’s argument – Twitter use did not contribute to direct action on the streets of Tehran – but misses an opportunity to investigate an odd parallel: thousands of people with internet access spent days fixated on a geographically-remote street protest.

Who was that fixated population? Amin Vafa suggests that young diasporic Iranians like himself (“lucky enough to move to the US back in the late 1980s”) may have played a critical role in the flurry of English-language activity on Twitter. He recalls obsessively seeking information to retweet, “I knew at the time it wasn’t much, but it was something.” Messages sent among family and friends within and without Iran provided countless small bridges between the primarily SMS-based communication paradigm in Iran and the tweet-based ecology of the US/EU.

Such connections among far-flung members of Iranian families represent strong ties of a type similar to those that Gladwell admires in the civil-rights movement. And Vafa’s experience suggests that the specific technological affordances of Twitter enabled people to exercise those ties on a transnational scale. This is not to recommend either Twitter or SMS as effective tools for organizing an uprising (when things get hectic, cell phone service is the first to go) but instead to highlight the critical importance of including technical detail in any discussion of social media activism.

What is “the civil-rights movement”?

Leaves blowing away

Gladwell presents the civil-rights movement as a touchstone for “traditional” activism. In vivid narrative passages, he recounts moments of breathtaking heroism among black activists in the face of hate, discrimination, and brutality. This bravery, he argues, was inspired by strong local ties and enabled by support from hierarchically-structured organizations like the N.A.A.C.P. The movement, as he finds it, was “disciplined”, “precise”, and “strategic”; systematically mobilizing thousands of participants in the execution of long-term plans toward well-defined goals. “If you’re taking on a powerful and organized establishment,” he concludes, “you have to be a hierarchy.”

Absent from this discussion, however, is consideration for the role of history in our present-day understanding of the civil-rights movement. During a visit to our research group last week, Steven Classen reminded us that our cultural memory of the civil-rights era is built on an incomplete record. Civil-rights activism was, in Gladwell’s terms, “high-risk” activism and carried the threat of injury or death. For this reason, activist communication was covert and empheral; the kind that does not leave traces to be collected and preserved in an archive.

Before the civil-rights movement can provide data to support an analysis of hierarchical activist organizations, consideration must be made for the thousands of “silent heroes” whose whose risks and labor were not recorded in any official history. Classen’s interviews and archival research revealed an enlarged history of the civil-rights movement in which the highly-visible actions of centralized organizations were accompanied by small acts of resistance among seemingly autonomous groups in rural communities throughout Mississippi. How should researchers account for these gaps and discrepancies? In spite of the sheer quantity of data produced by today’s social media use, there will always be aspects of social movements that are lost, forgotten, obscured, and excluded.

The same risk of injury that once obscured many human stories from the dominant history of the civil-rights movement is fundamental to Gladwell’s categorization of different types of activism. On one hand, he is right to distinguish “high-risk” activism like the civil-rights movement from comparatively safe acts like joining a Facebook Cause but when he writes that, “activism that challenges the status quo [...] is not for the faint of heart”, he seems to imply that violence is a necessary condition for effecting social change. In response, Linda Raftree recalls the nerve-wracking experience of carrying a politically-themed t-shirt through the streets of El Salvador in the early 1990s. The very same act that seems innocuous to a U.S. citizen can be extremely risky within a different political regime. As social media networks and their users increasingly cross national boundaries, the line between “high” and “low” risks will blur. Depending on one’s geographic, cultural, and religious position, participation in social media activism may involve considerable risks: social ostracization, joblessness, displacement, or spiritual alienation.

What works?

Screenshot from an It Gets Better video

The most hierarchical organizations in the civil-rights movement focused on (and succeeded in changing) the most hierarchical problems they faced: discriminatory laws and policies. But racism is not a highly-structured problem. In fact, racism is a dispersed, slippery evil that circulates, mutates, and evolves as it moves through groups of people across time and space. The hierarchical civil-rights movement defeated Jim Crow, an instantiation of racism, but could not eradicate racism itself.

Perhaps network problems like racism require non-hierarchical, network solutions. Stetson Kennedy’s “Frown Power” campaign of the 1940s and 1950s was an effort to address racism in a network fashion. To combat everyday racism, Kennedy encouraged anti-racist whites to respond to racist remarks simply by frowning. Dan Savage’s It Gets Better project is a similar present-day example. Angered and saddened by the persistence of homophobic bullying among high school students, Savage asks queer adults to speak directly to victimized teens using web video. Both campaigns are activism for the “faint of heart”. They effect a slow, quiet change rather than large-scale revolution.

And maybe a focus on outcomes is what this conversation needs. Creating a hard distinction between “traditional” activism and “social media” activism is a dead end. Whether the medium is Twitter, pirate radio, a drum, or lanterns hung in a Boston church tower, “real world” activism depends on the tactical selection of social media technologies. Rather than fret about “slacktivism” or dismiss popular new tools because of their hype, we should be looking critically at history for examples of network campaigns like Frown Power that take advantage of their culture and technological circumstances to effect new kinds of social change.

75 Responses to “Perhaps a revolution is not what we need”

  1. W+I » What revolution, and why are we tweeting it? Says:

    [...] find it problematic how Gladwell seeks to draw these lines between such activities and networks. As Kevin Driscoll, a student of Jenkins’, puts it: Creating a hard distinction between [...]

  2. Charlie Says:

    I think the point about Twitter’s flexibility and that its “norms emerge, mutate, collide, and fade away” fluidly is a really important point and adds another layer in which Gladwell’s false distinction between online and traditional activism seems cracked. By using the example of SNCC at Woolworth’s, Gladwell is isolating an effective sit-in some 50 years after its occurrence when its impact can be fairly well understood (though I think Ron Burnett makes a good point about other sit-ins not lasting in our cultural memories). In this context, of course Twitter and other social media platforms aren’t going to compare – they’re in their nascent stages and are surrounded by rapidly shifting norms (to say nothing of the lack of parallel between sit-ins and Twitter – a better comparison would be the conversations that made people beyond those in Greensboro aware of the sit-ins and Twitter).

    More than anything else, this serves to make the parallel between “Frown Power” and “It Gets Better” more interesting because it draws a parallel between two different network-based solutions – but I think it ultimately runs into a similar problem as what I mentioned with Twitter. Savage’s YouTube campaign could create social change and make teens feel like it gets better, but it may not ultimately have a large impact (though certainly there has been a lot of buzz around it, I think most of that is due to its timeliness and potential, not effectiveness).

    I guess this leads to me to my ultimate question and reason for posting this – how do we focus on outcomes when the development of these tools and campaigns is still occurring? I feel like emphasizing outcomes sometimes begets sometimes premature historicizing where we write about technology as if it has created the sort of change we dream it will.

    More, I wonder about the focus on outcomes in non-hierarchical, grassroots change because I feel like it encourages inappropriate application of metrics, and I wonder if that’s part of where Gladwell’s problem lies. He seems to value concrete progress above anything else, and while we can see laws change, it’s almost impossible to see perspectives change except retroactively. So I guess while I agree about the importance of outcomes, I wonder how we can actually employ that in contemporary analyses of social media.

  3. KU Social Media » Week 8 Assignments Says:

    [...] Perhaps a revolution is not what we need by Malcolm Gladwell and the consideration of that same topic by Henry Jenkins on his blog Confessions of an ACA-Fan Oct. 8. 2010. [...]

  4. Deeper reading: leadership, thinking for yourself and participation in the digital age | Robi Ganguly's Big Ideas Says:

    [...] Kevin Driscoll’s blog post, which is fascinating because he dissects Gladwell’s lack of understanding about the nuances of the technology utilized by Twitter and also corrects the historical records of the civil rights movement which Gladwell seeks to simplify. I found that he persuasively shifted the conversation to a focus on outcomes. Ultimately, distinctions between new and old participation make less sense than an understanding of how to utilize the networks and tools (in his phrasing, taking advantage of the current cultural and technological circumstances ) of today to push new social changes. Sounds much more reasonable to me. [...]

  5. “Por qué la revolución no será twiteada” (en inglés) @ qultura Says:

    [...] Malcolm Gladwell y publicado en el New Yorker el 29 de Septiembre, 2010. Además, este link a una respuesta de Kevin Driscoll “Quizás una revolución no es lo que [...]

  6. A Part of the Change Says:

    [...] Kevin Driscoll’s critique of Gladwell’s article, he explains that Gladwell has overlooked certain aspects of the [...]

  7. CoLab Radio » Blog Archive » What makes people listen? Gladwell Response Round Up Says:

    [...] •  Kevin Driscoll – Perhaps a revolution is not what we need [...]

  8. Kory Reasinger Says:

    Its such as you learn my thoughts! You appear to understand so much approximately this, such as you wrote the guide in it or something. I feel that you just could do with a few p.c. to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, that is fantastic blog. A fantastic read. I will certainly be back.

  9. Vending Says:

    @Agnostic Indian We are not disturbed by the horror stories.

  10. Nicholas Froozy Says:

    Your web site is timely reinforcement with regard to the intent behind blogs and a few things i anticipate to also. Truly good one!

  11. Petronila Tarling Says:

    Jesus Christ there is plenty of spammy comments on this web site. Have you actually thought about attempting to remove them or putting in a tool?

  12. Booker Borello Says:

    This is such an informationrmative post and very clearly written. Every single thought and idea is direct to the point. Perfectly laid out. thanx for taking your time sharing this to you scaners.

  13. Fausto Hilton Says:

    Wonderful blog you have here but I was curious if you knew of any discussion boards that cover the same topics discussed in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get advice from other knowledgeable individuals that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Bless you!

  14. proothishi istoselidas Says:

    Well I definitely enjoyed reading it. This article procured by you is very helpful for good planning.

  15. gift ideas Says:

    Hello would you mind letting me know which webhost you’re working with? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different web browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot faster then most. Can you recommend a good web hosting provider at a honest price? Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!

  16. homemade gifts Says:

    Thanks for your post on this blog. From my personal experience, there are occassions when softening up a photograph may possibly provide the professional photographer with an amount of an artistic flare. Oftentimes however, the soft clouds isn’t just what you had in mind and can sometimes spoil an otherwise good photograph, especially if you thinking about enlarging it.

  17. Atlanta Says:

    One other thing is that an online business administration training is designed for students to be able to smoothly proceed to bachelors degree education. The Ninety credit college degree meets the other bachelor education requirements when you earn your current associate of arts in BA online, you may have access to the modern technologies in this field. Some reasons why students want to be able to get their associate degree in business is because they can be interested in this area and want to obtain the general instruction necessary ahead of jumping in a bachelor education program. Many thanks for the tips you provide as part of your blog.

  18. Project First Sale Mark Wilson Says:

    Hi there are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own. Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  19. Cibcungen seo Says:

    naturally like your web site however you have to take a look at the spelling on quite a few of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling issues and I in finding it very bothersome to inform the truth then again I’ll definitely come again again.

  20. filme seriale online Says:

    Hi ene France aas urilga avsan geed Och gedeg hun ali hotoos ireh ve? Paris t baidag uu? nadad Parisaas shuud Berlin oroh hun heregtei baih yum. Holboo barina uu.

  21. Roberto Wenck Says:

    I see something truly special in this site.

  22. WarriorForum Says:

    I loved up to you will obtain carried out proper here. The caricature is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish. however, you command get got an shakiness over that you wish be turning in the following. unwell for sure come more beforehand once more since exactly the similar nearly very often inside of case you shield this hike.

  23. polo shirts for women cheap Says:

    The quality and durability sold within this musician will help you users maintain any type of piece of fashion in a very long time if it turns out looked after nicely.

  24. garcinia cambogia extract Says:

    Some actually nice stuff on this internet website , I adore it.

  25. Maxine Kusinski Says:

    Whats up this is excellent! would you want to blogroll trade with myself? I think we will both equally gain because of interchanging back links and traffic.

  26. rocketport 8 Port rs 232 Says:

    I sorry not speak good English.What i don’t realize is actually how you are now not really much more well-favored than you might be right now. You’re very intelligent. You realize therefore significantly on the subject of this matter, produced me in my view consider it from a lot of varied angles. Its like women and men are not fascinated except it’s something to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your personal stuffs great. All the time handle it up!

  27. cheap health insurance Illinois Says:

    Someone essentially assist to make significantly articles I might state. That is the very first time I frequented your web page and to this point? I amazed with the analysis you made to create this particular put up incredible. Magnificent task!

  28. Hoffman Estates garage door repair Says:

    Some really nice and useful information on this site, besides I think the design and style has wonderful features.

  29. Northbrook handy man Says:

    I think this internet site contains very wonderful composed subject material blog posts.

  30. what e cigarette is the best Says:

    What are you indicating, man? I understand everyones got their own opinion, but really? Listen, your web log is interesting. I like the hard work you put into it, particularly with the vids and the pics. But, come on. Theres gotta be a better way to say this, a way that doesnt make it seem like everyone here is stupid!

  31. Levi Preast Says:

    Thanks on behalf of the promising writeup. It in truth was once a leisure account it. Glance higher to added delivered agreeable starting you! By the way, how can we keep in touch?

  32. Innovation Management Says:

    This is the right webpage for anybody who would like to understand this topic. You realize so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I actually will need to…HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a subject which has been discussed for a long time. Excellent stuff, just wonderful!

  33. here Says:

    Hi” best wishes to you and your quite great weblog,

  34. key lime salt scrub Says:

    My partner and I absolutely love your blog and find the majority of your post’s to be what precisely I’m looking for. Would you offer guest writers to write content available for you? I wouldn’t mind writing a post or elaborating on some of the subjects you write regarding here. Again, awesome web log!

  35. vanilla salt scrub Says:

    It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d definitely donate to this fantastic blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this website with my Facebook group. Chat soon!

  36. nha hang tiec cuoi Says:

    We stumbled over here from a different page and thought I might check things out. I like what I see so i am just following you. Look forward to checking out your web page for a second time.

  37. Carey Manry Says:

    Wow! This can be one particular of the most helpful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Basically Fantastic. I’m also a specialist in this topic so I can understand your effort.

  38. True Value Solar Says:

    Hiya! I know this is kinda off topic however I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest authoring a blog article or vice-versa? My blog covers a lot of the same topics as yours and I feel we could greatly benefit from each other. If you are interested feel free to shoot me an e-mail. I look forward to hearing from you! Awesome blog by the way!

  39. Seriale online Says:

    Wow, incredible blog format! How lengthy have you ever been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The whole look of your site is excellent, let alone the content material!

  40. Says:

    Hi, just wanted to tell you, I enjoyed this post. It was helpful. Keep on posting!

  41. Madelyn Fey Says:

    Hiya, I am really glad I’ve found this info. Nowadays bloggers publish only about gossip and internet stuff and this is actually annoying. A good site with interesting content, that is what I need. Thank you for making this web site, and I will be visiting again. Do you do newsletters? I Cant find it.

  42. reputation management service Says:

    Excellent post! We are linking to this particularly great post on our site.
    Keep up the great writing.

  43. filme 2009 Says:

    hi! , I love your own creating pretty so much! percent most people continue your messages excess roughly your current article in Yahoo? I require a professional of this type to eliminate this difficulty. Perhaps which is people! Looking onward to search you.

  44. ass Says:

    You ought to take part in a contest for one of the most useful blogs on the web. I will recommend this web site!

  45. tiffany jewelry on sale Says:

    You might want to earn a stylish unvarying for your very own team, then you have got to go for your padded polo tee shirt. You could make your employees put all of the padded shirts that have the emblem with the company specialists have these commercial on the small business with the stitched polo clothing. This is often a very original web marketing strategy ,polo shirt ralph lauren,basically because nowadays in this era, that marketing understanding is simply not regularly taken on by many business enterprise and corporate has.

  46. DoD Information Assurance Says:

    What fun activity relating to female firefighters can I make my class do?

  47. where to find the best golf lessons Says:

    Your blog is incredible dude. i really like to go to it everyday. really great layout and content material “

  48. lectura de las cartas Says:

    Los cursos constituyen la mejor manera para salir de la crisis, y hacerlo bajo soporte web como esta página es sin duda el futuro que toca a los desarrolladores de contenidos de cursos a distancia , Buenos tardes y que tengan una jornada estupendo.

  49. Thaddeus Scarpitto Says:

    Between me and my spouse we’ve owned more MP3 players more than the years than I can depend, like Sansas, iRivers, iPods (vintage & contact), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last couple of a long time I’ve settled down to 1 line of players. Why? Since I was happy to discover how nicely-created and exciting to use the underappreciated (and widely mocked) Zunes are.

  50. Get Away Today Julie Smith Says:

    I am curious to find out what blog platform you happen to be working with?
    I’m having some minor security problems with my latest site and I’d like
    to find something more safeguarded. Do you have any recommendations?

  51. like this Says:

    I like this blog its a master peace ! Glad I noticed this on google. “Irrationally held truths may be more harmful than reasoned errors.” by Thomas Huxley.

  52. Crazy Mass - Body Building Says:

    Thank you a lot for sharing this with all people you really know what you’re speaking approximately! Bookmarked. Please additionally consult with my site =). We can have a hyperlink change arrangement between us! CrazyMass – Body Building

  53. reputation management Says:

    Wow! This blog looks exactly like my old one!

    It’s on a completely different topic but it has pretty much the same layout and design.
    Wonderful choice of colors!

  54. Quinton Salomon Says:

    Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is great, as well as the content!. Thanks For Your article about Civics, Popular Media & Participatory Culture» Blog Archive » Perhaps a revolution is not what we need .

  55. bradley kurgis Says:

    These are really impressive ideas in regarding blogging.
    You have touched some nice factors here. Any way keep up wrinting.

    Here is my web-site: bradley kurgis

  56. Buddy Juarbe Says:

    “I have to say that for the past few of hours i have been hooked by the impressive articles on this site. Keep up the great work.”

  57. Ripped Muscle X Reviews Says:

    An intriguing discussion is definitely worth comment. In my opinion that you must write more with this subject matter, it may not be a taboo subject but an average of people do not speak about these issues. To another! Cheers!!

  58. go Says:

    The new Zune browser is surprisingly good, but not as good as the iPod’s. It works well, but isn’t as fast as Safari, and has a clunkier interface. If you occasionally plan on using the web browser that’s not an issue, but if you’re planning to browse the web alot from your PMP then the iPod’s larger screen and better browser may be important.

  59. Cherri Cooner Says:

    Wow, wonderful blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is fantastic, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Civics, Popular Media & Participatory Culture» Blog Archive » Perhaps a revolution is not what we need .

  60. Cherri Cooner Says:

    Wow, awesome blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your website is fantastic, as well as the content!. Thanks For Your article about Civics, Popular Media & Participatory Culture» Blog Archive » Perhaps a revolution is not what we need .

  61. zyloslim Says:

    Whoa! This blog looks exactly like my old one! It’s on a entirely different subject but it has pretty much the same page layout and design. Wonderful choice of colors!

  62. Gothic Sex Says:

    I wonder if some of this stuff might have been plagiarized, it’s all over the internet and other peoples websites, unless you’re the content’s author?.

  63. dunhill pipe tobacco Says:

    Hello you cos i so absolutely dig your nice blog, I would feel very special if i could publish a review about your awesome work on my little would you say yes?

  64. snort this Says:

    Outstanding post, I conceive people should acquire a lot from this web blog its real user genial. So much great info on here :D.

  65. buy pure garcinia cambogia Says:

    Woah this particular website is actually wonderful i adore looking through your content. Stay the superior works of art! You already know, lots of individuals need all-around just for this info, you may support them drastically.

  66. tobacco pipes Says:

    Hello, Good morning cos i so very much like your original blog, I would feel special if you would like to me write a bloomy review on this work on my own would you say yes please?

  67. Natural Cosmetics Says:

    hi!,I really like your writing very much! proportion we be in contact more about your post on AOL? I require a specialist on this space to resolve my problem. May be that is you! Looking forward to look you.

  68. JNL Fusion Says:

    You need to be a part of a match for just one of the highest quality sites on the net. I most certainly can suggest this internet site!|You need to be considered a part of a contest for one of the highest-quality sites on the net. I definitely will recommend this website!

  69. dachy epdm Says:

    Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn something like this before. So good to search out any person with some authentic thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for beginning this up. this web site is something that is needed on the net, someone with just a little originality. useful job for bringing one thing new to the web!

  70. Centrodyne s700 taximeter Says:

    More individuals need to study this and understand this aspect of the story. I cant believe you’re not more popular.

  71. Emilee Partee Says:

    An accountancy practice pics of swimsuit lolitas OK she’s cute, but not THAT cute… so why does this video show up on EVERY related video?! Bloody great tagging, methinks!

  72. best penis growth pills Says:

    hey there and thank you for your information Ive definitely picked up anything new from right here. I did however expertise several technical points using this website, since I experienced to reload the web site many times previous to I could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK? Not that I am complaining, but slow loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement in google and can damage your high quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Well Im adding this RSS to my email and can look out for a lot more of your respective intriguing content. Ensure that you update this again soon..

  73. penis enlargement that actually works Says:

    Good write-up, Im regular visitor of ones web site, maintain up the excellent operate, and It is going to be a regular visitor for a long time.

  74. compare home loan rates Says:

    Its fantastic as your other blog posts : D, appreciate it for posting . “A single day is enough to make us a little larger.” by Paul Klee.

  75. clavage Says:

    Very discreet pictures:

Leave a Reply